These essays describe the contours of the theology of the seventeenthcentury english general baptists thomas. The book deals with the question of altar calls, as the subtitle suggests, but its greatest value, i think, is that this is a classic example of the kind of warmhearted, evangelistic, classic calvinism that i appreciate, and its a great antidote to the ugly calvinism i spoke about that you find in internet forums. Popular calvinism books meet your next favorite book. Mckellar, a longtime pastor and expository preacher and also a former trustee, is now associate professor of preaching here at. Its amazing the amount of misunderstanding, confusion and misrepresentation that goes on in the discussion of the sovereignty of. In fact, it seems to be his primary motivation even in defending ergun caner. Institutes of the christian religion, 2 vols by john calvin, for calvinism by michael s. This book, if you can call it that, is really short, very flimsy, poorly written and researched and full of errors and straw men and semipelagian views.
I think real calvinism has brought good things to southern baptists, but i just wanted to write you and mention that your present contention is not with real calvinism. Can salvation depend on your position on calvinism. The traditional statement and semipelagianism by peter lumpkins. Macarthurs calvinism an analysis of john calvins tulip. If this kind of calvinism prospers, then genuine biblical piety will be under attack as never before. Baptist confessions of faith by william lumpkin is published by judson press. Nov 24, 2014 is lifeway pushing calvinism through the gospel project.
In this work he means to show that calvinism is both deeper and richer than the wellknown 5 points a. New calvinism the merger of calvinism with worldliness. Navigating the rising waters of reformed theology in the southern baptist convention kindle edition by lumpkins, peter. Peters blog features often news of interest to baptists well if a well known baptist writer is being accused then its news.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Calvinism also called the reformed tradition, reformed christianity, reformed protestantism, or the reformed faith is a major branch of protestantism that follows the theological tradition and forms of christian practice set down by john calvin and other reformationera theologians. Not only did james white twice slanderously implicate adam harwood in defending a pelagian. It was a welcome relief that these two were not spreading the lies and innuendo which they are accustomed to. Gresham machen professor of systematic theology and apologetics at westminster seminary california seeks to deal with these. Calvinism and the london baptist confession of 1644 part 1. A wordhonoring debate on calvinism musings of a mere. Wade burleson put his name on his criticism of pl, as did most others. Simply mention the word calvinism in certain circles and watch the emotional responses. In fact, of course, all calvinists will say that peters a calvinist.
So, lets first turn to the question this little book poseswhat is calvinism. While lutheranism was largely confined to parts of germany and to. Matthew pinson presents a collection of historicaltheological essays from the vantage point of a variety of arminianism coming to be known as reformed arminianism. Calvinism has been the target of countless caricatures, but none so misguided as the notion that it is the enemy of joy. Dear peter, i write to you as a fellow southern baptist. Peter lumpkins on james whites obsession ergun caner.
Some will remember peter lumpkins, a blogger and author of a new book on all you need to know about calvinismactually, a pamphlet of about 34 pages of actual text written by peter himself. Nearly 99% of the quote is actually al mohlers own words. Horton observes, in the section titled calvinism and christian missions p. Peter lumpkins didnt go around hunting for people that would make accusations against merritt. He has been a vociferous, vocal, but surely not deep, opponent of reformed theology for quite some time. Curtis hutson 19341995 the term calvinism is loosely used by some people who do not hold calvins teaching on predestination and do not understand exactly what calvin taught. The author of the book is a young man around 26 when he wrote it who grew up in a christian family and trained in secular journalism. Postgraduate work in bioethics, trinity international university. Recently, i posted a link on my blog to an article on peter lumpkins blog by a nonfundamentalist, evangelical calvinist blasting the new calvinism at least part of the young, restless, reformed movement.
Ramblings of a noncalvinist in the sbc by peter lumpkins posted on march 6, 2012 by sbc and calvinism the following is an article sbc blogger peter lumpkins wrote in 2007 and reposted it again today at sbc tomorrow. But the hands down no comparison most thorough and biblical refutation of 5 point tulip reformed calvinism is. His treatment of scripture borders on flippant, his distaste for logic which he equates with systematic theology is fully apparent, and his conclusions lack any practical use altogether. The five points of calvinism total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace, and the perseverance of the saintswere first defined by the synod of dordrecht years after calvins death in response to the theological positions of arminius. Gerald harris of the christian index poses that question to the southern baptist calvinism advisory committee in an editorial entitled a new kind of calvinism and linked to on peter lumpkins blog, synergism tomorrow. Peter s blog features often news of interest to baptists well if a well known baptist writer is being accused then its news. I was interested to read through a new little booklet written by ian hamilton, pastor of cambridge presbyterian church in cambridge, england. Andrew fuller or fullerism while admittedly a form of calvinism is shown in this book to be an exciting and vibrant alternative to historic reformed theologyparticularly for baptists and other freechurch traditions. The term also refers to doctrines and practices derived from the works of calvin and his followers that are characteristic of the reformed churches. Mar 06, 2012 ramblings of a noncalvinist in the sbc by peter lumpkins posted on march 6, 2012 by sbc and calvinism the following is an article sbc blogger peter lumpkins wrote in 2007 and reposted it again today at sbc tomorrow. Servetus was guilty of heresy which was against the law 4. Most of these responses sadly will be a caricature of the position based on misunderstandings that people have about calvinism.
Then switched over to a response to yesterdays attempted response by peter lumpkins, taking the opportunity to go a little more indepth into the issues raised, as the strawman argument lumpkins presented i. Let joe bidens nauseating performance illustrate how calvinists many times come across to average southern baptists. A view on peter lumpkins mockery of james white sbc tomorrows peter lumpkins has been taking james whites critical approach towards ergun caner to task. Apr 12, 20 april 12, 20 james white reformed apologetics comments off on open invitation to peter lumpkins open invitation to peter lumpkins. Loraine boettner in his book, the reformed doctrine of. Top five books on calvinism credo house ministries. By gol june 27, 2012 june 21st, 2019 blog, five points of calvinism. Why i disagree with all 5 points of calvinism by dr. Reading this book will inform your mind and warm your heart both of which the reformers were concerned to do in order. Aug 06, 2012 peter lumpkins didnt go around hunting for people that would make accusations against merritt. The problem is, lumpkins quote of white is of white quoting al mohler.
Apr 02, 2020 calvinism, the theology advanced by john calvin, a protestant reformer in the 16th century, and its development by his followers. Calvinism, the theology advanced by john calvin, a protestant reformer in the 16th century, and its development by his followers. It is really unfair and unchristian to bash peter lumpkins here. Navigating the rising waters of reformed theology in the southern baptist. Peter lumpkins, a supposed mature christian southern baptist minister, has proved to everyone how infantile he is with his vicious and deliberate caricature attacking dr. Calvinism is also known for its strong emphasis on gods allcontrolling sovereignty. Ramblings of a noncalvinist in the sbc by peter lumpkins.
Navigating the rising waters of reformed theology in the southern baptist convention. This second booklet in the free church press booklet series was released in march 20. I enjoy peter s writing, especially when i disagree with him. It is hard to find a book dealing with religion or history of religion that does not mention calvinism in some way. This book strengthened my faith that the reformed view is correct. Calvin, john calvin, oil painting by an anonymous master of the. Oct 12, 2012 this week in calvinism october 12, 2012 what peter lumpkins gleaned from the vice presidential debate. If you dont know what a calvinist is just find my little lesson entitled, what is calvinism. The accusation that calvinism leads to antimission sentiments has sometimes been leveled, but as michael horton shows in his recent book for calvin, nothing could be further from the truth. This post is inspired by a recent blog by peter lumpkins that details some views of b. White addressed a recent calvinism dialogue at southwestern theological seminary and the comments made from both sides. Peter lumpkins, following misstep after misstep, finally started blogging on matters where lies are less frequently required.
Mention the word calvinism and youre likely to get some strong negative responses. Horton is a book i highly recommend everyone read especially those who think they understand calvinism but misunderstand what calvinism teaches, and or mislead others by promoting caricatures of calvinism. Calvinism is not new to baptists grace unleashed in the american colonies. Recently, i posted a link on my blog to an article on peter lumpkins blog by a. Open invitation to peter lumpkins alpha and omega ministries. April 12, 20 james white reformed apologetics comments off on open invitation to peter lumpkins open invitation to peter lumpkins. Wipf and stock publishers book description calvinism and its impact upon baptist and other freechurch traditions is an issue of perennial importance. Honorable mentions would be books refuting calvinism by the following authors. Peter smith and some others were thought rather arminian. What peter lumpkins gleaned from the vice presidential debate.
His treatment of scripture borders on flippant, his distaste for logic which he equates with systematic theology is fully apparent, and. Jan 22, 2014 peter lumpkins sets straight james white on calvins execution of servetus. Calvinism summer 2004 wednesday night adult class lesson 1 page 2 of 5 pervasive influence of calvinism in the religious world probably no mortal man has exercised more influence on the religious world than john calvin. This twovolume collection contains awardwinning author michael hortons for calvinism which takes you beyond the caricatures of calvinism and immersing you into the true, biblical teachings it offers, and roger olsons against calvinism, which offers objections to socalled new calvinism a movement being embraced by the young, restless, reformed generation. John mark caton, senior pastor of cottonwood creek baptist church and former chairman of the board of trustees at southwestern baptist theological seminary, moderated a dialogue on calvinism between dr. Agree or disagree, peter lumpkins puts his name on what he writes. Jan 27, 2017 while calvin and calvinists may have been an undeniable influence in the christian church beginning in the reformation era, writes peter lumpkins, it remains beyond difficult to imagine, in the face of so much evidence to the contrary, that calvin and calvinism positively contributed to establishing religious freedom in the fabric of american culture and embedding it into the law of the land. In for calvinism, michael horton professor of systematic theology and. Some will remember peter lumpkins, a blogger and author of a new book on all you need to know about calvinism actually, a pamphlet of about 34 pages of actual text written by peter himself. Step 3, claim as does peter lumpkins lol that you were once a calvinist or raised a calvinist and youve seen the light in order to gain credibility. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the storms of calvinism. Peter lumpkins is a southern baptist minister living in west georgia.
An recent article at a southern baptist oriented blog used the term baptist bogeyman to refer to immaterial things southern baptist get worked up about, creating bogeymen to fight while ignoring the true enemy. Peter lumpkins laments the arrogance and intractability of calvinists while displaying, in his writing, the self. Beginning early in the 1980s, two of his books, one of which was. While many criticisms have been levelled against baptist calvinists through the years some true, some false, one charge, at least in some ways, outranks them allcalvinists are arrogant, knowitall. I have rarely, if ever, met a southern baptist who was violently opposed to calvinism not say i was raised in that or i use to think that way. Concerning the eternal predestination of god by john calvin.
And in a sense, this is the ultimate doctrine upon which all the other 5 points rest, and which separate calvinism from the mancentered arminianism and thomism etc, to which the rest of christianity in america hold. Boyce more than appreciated calvinistic theologyhe was raised by a mother. Its a joke to suggest servetus broke no laws in geneva. Zane hodges john r rice david cloud peter ruckman robert lightner and to a degree rt kendall. Forster insists rightly that calvinism is drenched with joy, and has done a masterful job of accounting for the beauty and delight intrinsic to biblical calvinism. There is so much heat generated with this topic youd think it was the most important doctrine of all.
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. Recently, i posted a link on my blog to an article on peter lumpkins blog by a nonfundamentalist, evangelical calvinist blasting the new calvinism at least part of. He found that a person made this claim and linked to it on a baptist blog. The anonymous commenter above, peaches, who assailed peter for lack of accomplishment should identify himherself. Revell, in an examination of several books that discussed the topic, noted that the same. Robert selph is published by gano books five succeeding reprints. Peter lumpkins resonds, ascol on garrett on calvinism in the alabama. For more than 20 years, peter served as a pastor in kentucky, tennessee and georgia. At the time of servetus arrest, no laws in geneva had been broken. Reformed theology continues to rise in influence in the southern b. Peter lumpkins laments the arrogance and intractability of calvinists while displaying, in his writing, the selfsame characteristics. The decline of confessional calvinism among baptist associations in the southern states during the nineteenth century. His latest post pushes the boundaries and is a pretty startling exhibition of mockery of james white.
1210 933 28 331 228 222 244 1058 1408 679 773 951 956 1425 1560 888 1576 1124 1472 1508 1571 1450 1400 1390 1449 322 1280 515 355 228 874 898 669 1433 455 235 1029 858 1120